"Hello Neil,
The Syncopation point is really good. I guess I am still scared or syncopation a little bit. I need (and i am Trying) to be a bit more brave while creating something new. Thanks a lot. p.s. I believe everybody is qualified to listen and…"
Music Composers Unite!
Kareem Kandiel's Discussions
I need critique!
Started this discussion. Last reply by Ali Riza SARAL Sep 18, 2019. 9 Replies 1 Like
Hello dear composers,I am a hobby musician/composer. I started recording my music just a year a go after 12 years of practicing classical guitar. As I have no musical training I tend to doubt myself…Continue
Kareem Kandiel's Page
Latest Activity
"Hi Kareem. I'm not sure how qualified I am to comment but here goes. I like the broad musical ideas. You have a strong theme towards the end of the piece which works very well. I would have liked more "support" for the piano from the…"
"Beautiful! Has some Baroque quality and/or influence to it. When I started trying to practice sightreading (the thing that I never managed) I used to try to follow videos like yours I find it really helpful."
"Thanks a lot. I am really thrilled you like it!"
"I have nothing to add to what's already been said,but I just wanted to let you know that I thought it's beautiful!"
"Hey Dane.. I didn't notice the Mediterranean touch. But I come originaly from Alexandria, Egypt. Thanks.. I will definitly take some time to learn about Harmony."
"you are righ, Bob. I can read music (only treble clef though) But it is only a self learn thing. Thanks a lot!"
"Very nice. Calm, a sombre mood, nice balance between piano and background strings. Has a Mediterranean feel to me.
There were a couple of small things that might benefit from revision later on but all in all, a great piece. Good length. I…"
"I would say that 12 years of playing guitar certainly counts as musical training. If you read music, that's also a plus because so much of theory is about what is on the printed page.
This piece shows that you have a good ear. Trust it. Would…"
I need critique!
Hello dear composers,I am a hobby musician/composer. I started recording my music just a year a go after 12 years of practicing classical guitar. As I have no musical training I tend to doubt myself being a composer. I only depend on my ears, mood and feelings when writing something new. I am sure that is not enough and I am planning to invest some time in music theory. Two days ago i finished a piece that I would like to share with you. any comment or critique is really appreciated.…See More
Profile Information
- What have you composed for? Or what medium do you work around?
- Film, Orchestra, Small Ensemble
- What is your favorite genre or style of music?
- Classical
- Is music your main income source?
- No - Not Yet
- Where do you live?
- Berlin, Germany
- About Me (Must include at least one paragraph of biographical information about you as a composer) - blank or minimal answers on this line will cause your request to be rejected. Include a link to your website if you have one.
- I am a hobby Guitarist, and Oud (Lute) player. I always find myself haunted with a tune in mind that I need to record or write down. So I started working around DAWs and VSTs.
I have no musical training so some insight and or input is what I need right now.
- Website:
- https://soundcloud.com/kmibrahim
Comment Wall (1 comment)
- At 8:54am on August 20, 2019,
Gav Brown said…
Welcome Kareem!
© 2021 Created by Gav Brown.
Powered by
