Composers' Forum

Music Composers Unite!

Carl Lingard
Share on Facebook
Share
  • Blog Posts
  • Discussions (14)
  • Events
  • Groups
  • Photos
  • Photo Albums
  • Videos

Carl Lingard's Discussions

Three original compositions

Started this discussion. Last reply by Ray Apr 29. 61 Replies

Hi, I'm new to this forum although I have been a member for a while now- just not had chance to come on here since I joined. As my first post hello to all! :-) I'm posting three original tracks. I…Continue

 

Carl Lingard's Page

Latest Activity

Dave Dexter replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"A thread started by a new member looking for advice is now, in addition to thankfully expunged claims of plagiarism, subject to this irrelevant nonsense. It perhaps puts my labelling of some members as stupid cunts into perspective."
Apr 29
Mike Hewer replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Carl, I would also change the rhythm of the tune along with its shape (contour). The difference between B minor and D major in this instance is just technical semantics as the difference between a bm7th or a D major chord is not enough to get you…"
Apr 28
Carl Lingard replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Shame, oh well! "
Apr 28
Dave Dexter replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Tbf, whilst I hear it in the verses, it took Nikola to point it out and I find it a slim similarity. As I said, the big hook of Crawford's is the chorus where the progression changes completely, and I don't hear that in your piece.Music…"
Apr 28
Dave Dexter replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"My regret here is being busy yesterday and missing whatever bilious meltdown led to this moment."
Apr 28
Carl Lingard replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Bob, that's a long time...haven't you had enough yet? :-D  Yes, I think it's a good approach to learn all the rules and then tear the rule book up!...or rather than anything so drastic, break one here and there or invent new…"
Apr 28
Carl Lingard replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Thanks for the advice Mike and for listening. I do have another version of the track and it is best left in the original key of Bm but the singer's range might be an issue. I'll probably just change the opening phrase a little. I think one…"
Apr 28
Carl Lingard replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Not a problem Dave. I did have that song in mind when I wrote it but I wasn't aware just how similar that phrase was. I do have another version which doesn't have any of the 'verse' material in it."
Apr 28
Carl Lingard replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
":-)...I'm always at pains to tell people that those tracks are pre-production. The internet is a great place for communication. Unfortunately things get so out of hand so quickly. Peace to everyone on here."
Apr 28
Carl Lingard replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Thank you Serenity for the kind words. I seem to have walked into a 'situation' haha. No bother. It's amazing how quickly things can escalate on the net, and how quickly people can resolve things too. Anyway, thanks for listening."
Apr 28
Carl Lingard replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Thanks for the words of advice Mike, yes the key was originally in Bm actually- it works better in that key as more sonorous but the singer's vocal range created problems. Having listened to it again and actually sat down and compared it I do…"
Apr 27
Carl Lingard replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Hahaha...true enough :-) I'm recording this track for the album though and will make a small change to that phrase in the melody. "
Apr 27
Mike Hewer replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Guys, I'm not going to speak from a legal standpoint because I'm not qualified to do so. However I can do it from a musical point of view and have to say that the first 4 bars from about 1' 15" in are exactly like One day. The…"
Apr 27
Greg Brus replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"Can't be bothered to read all this, but do I need to torch some people?"
Apr 27
Dave Dexter replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"It doesn't really come up tbh - this debacle is the first time I've seen one member point the plagiarism finger at another - but Mike Hewer is probably a good man to ask (if he doesn't mind!), what with his industry experience and…"
Apr 27
Dave Dexter replied to Carl Lingard's discussion Three original compositions
"I did actually state some similarities myself, just nowhere near enough to justify accusations of plagiarism, and of course you've ignored that. I can find you the quote if you like.Now, let's examine the situation in a wider context. A…"
Apr 27

Profile Information

What have you composed for? Or what medium do you work around?
Songs, Other
What is your favorite genre or style of music?
Good music
Is music your main income source?
No - Not Yet
Where do you live?
Manchester, UK
About Me (Must include biographical information about you as a composer):
I write for a band: pop, rock and jazz, but I also like to learn and use new things: composition, arranging, orchestration.

Comment Wall (1 comment)

You need to be a member of Composers' Forum to add comments!

Join Composers' Forum

At 5:30pm on October 25, 2015, Tyler Hughes said…

Welcome to the Composers' Forum 

 
 
 

© 2017   Created by Chris Merritt.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service