At the suggestion of several members, I have added some requisite screening questions for newly registering members. Registrants' responses will remain private.

Home

Activity

David Seymour and Ahmed Khan are now friends
yesterday
Stephen Ferre commented on Stephen Ferre's blog post 2 New works posted
"FYI, the scrolling video of the trumpet concerto was an intermediate version before I translated it into Dorico, so it has a number of empty staves. They aren't in the final score."
yesterday
Stephen Ferre posted a blog post
I've posted some of my frustrations with learning Dorico before, but I just set my first string quartet in it. It isn't long, so it basically took me 3 days to come up with a satisfactory setting. The piece is from 1987, although I've made some…
yesterday
Dave Dexter replied to Guy Shahar's discussion Are these double stops playable?
"A quick method to check, since you play guitar iirc, is to tune it to the right intervals and then fret the shapes yourself. If they're awkward to you, they will be to the string player. Fifths, for example, are very playable. Outside that, there…"
Saturday
Guy Shahar posted a discussion
6 months into my composing journey, I've finally attempted a short allegro movement for the first time. Is it normal that it's SO much more work than a slower piece?It's the opening to my 5th String Quintet, and includes also includes double stops…
Wednesday
Saul Gefen replied to Saul Gefen's discussion String Symphony In D major No. 3
"Hi Ivor, you make a valid point. Thanks a lot for listening and for commenting.
 
Best Wishes,
 
Saul"
Dec 28, 2024
Gerd Prengel replied to Gerd Prengel's discussion Variations for piano in g-minor on an early Beethoven draft
"Thank you, Ivor, for your appreciation - I am glad that it speaks to you ...  :-)  "
Dec 27, 2024
David replied to Ivor's discussion Symphonic Movement for Strings (4 mins 20 secs)
"no telly allowed where I was for Xmas but the first thing watched when getting back was "Servant of the People" (Sluga naroda) which reminded me Zelensky actually used to be really funny. My composer hat will probably remain on the stand until I get…"
Dec 27, 2024
Ivor replied to Gerd Prengel's discussion Variations for piano in g-minor on an early Beethoven draft
"This is something you're very good at, Gerd. Need I say more?
Most pleasant to listen to.
All the best, Ivor"
Dec 27, 2024
Ivor replied to Saul Gefen's discussion String Symphony In D major No. 3
"Nice piece, Saul, easy to listen to. I know we agreed not to review each other's work but I had time to spare. You also know my disdain for 'tonal' even if I fall into it myself at times.
It would have been nicer if the second part was in a…"
Dec 27, 2024
Ivor replied to Ivor's discussion Symphonic Movement for Strings (4 mins 20 secs)
"Thank you, David, for listening and your comment. You seem to have felt the mood. It isn't one of my "usual" moods personally but it actually leaves me empty when I listen to it. Frankly, I'm surprised it worked out at all which is more than I can…"
Dec 27, 2024
Ivor replied to Ivor's discussion Symphonic Movement for Strings (4 mins 20 secs)
"Many thanks for your comment and listening. Yes, the Locrian and like Mennin I put triads on each other the notes which accounts for the "major" sounding cadences VI-II in this mode.  
I'm still fond of Mennin's work. If anyone tempted me toward…"
Dec 27, 2024
David replied to Rowy's discussion Let it snow
"I had actually thought about the VSL solo voices when on sale as they're certainly better than their substandard choirs but I'm still reluctant to get anything which doesn't sing free text (with one small exception). VSL seem to offer the option of…"
Dec 19, 2024
Rowy replied to Rowy's discussion Let it snow
"The Beatles. They were very popular when I was a teenager. I can't remember this song, so I can't tell if your arrangement stayed true to the original. Perhaps that's not what you're aiming for. It sounds a bit eerie and somewhat contemporary. A bit…"
Dec 19, 2024
Guy Shahar replied to Rowy's discussion Let it snow
"How did you get the vsl problem resolved.   I've just bought their solo voices and didn't realise you couldn't use them offline without paying an extra 50 quid for special usb ilok thing that's probably very easy to lose…   what were the problems…"
Dec 19, 2024
Guy Shahar replied to Rowy's discussion Let it snow
" That sounds like a nice bit of Christmas fun.   I also like the one you shared with David (less Christmassy but perhaps a better piece).   I'd love to hear some of your free counterpoint if you're willing to share - sounds very interesting. 
I have…"
Dec 19, 2024
More…

You need to be a member of composersforum to add comments!

Join composersforum

Comments are closed.

Comments

  • Oh, and please welcome our new members, if you have a chance.
  • I've allowed a few new prospective members through. If you should observe signs of bother, abuse, or any other matter that arouses suspicion, please advise me promptly.. Thanks all.
  • Indeed, it has been solved. Thanks for the prompt response!
  • HS, I believe I've isolated the HTML issue mentioned, and I believe it's now resolved. Thanks for bringing it to my attention.
  • Thanks HS. I'll investigate the matter.
  • Hmm, interesting. I just noticed that replies under the Discussion Forum do allow full HTML capabilities, but replies under Analysis & Critique don't. Maybe this is a section-specific setting that needs to be toggled?
  • It's been a while since somebody wrote something here. So I thought I'd bring up this request to allow links and attachments in comments, not just in posts. It would make it easier to have in-depth discussions without needing to create a new thread every time somebody wants to attach something to illustrate their ideas.
  • ok - that sounds like a good setting so will be interesting to see what the explanation (if any) is.
  • David, puzzling, because the site's settings at present bar members who aren't "friended" from sending private messages. I'll look into it.
  • As newest member Erica Woodward sent a message to at least one member wanting to urgently discuss something privately, it is to suspected that we have another spammer. If I remember correctly, on the old forum, prospective members had to submit a couple of sentences (which weren't posted publicly) explaining why they wanted to join the forum. I suspect spambots and others who are not serious about contributing would fall at this hurdle and I suggest something like this for possible consideration by the membership.
This reply was deleted.