Composers' Forum

Music Composers Unite!

John Elliott's Comments

Comment Wall (18 comments)

You need to be a member of Composers' Forum to add comments!

Join Composers' Forum

At 3:47pm on May 19, 2012, Nobuyoshi Tanaka said…

I like Stravinsky too! Yes, I feel it in your music :-)

At 11:15pm on May 18, 2012, Nobuyoshi Tanaka said…

I enjoyed listening your music. It seems like "neoclassicism" to me. Thanks!

At 2:03am on September 15, 2010, Rican Lee said…
beautiful work.
At 5:28pm on March 29, 2010, Yaiza Varona said…
Hi John!
Alas I found a little time to listen to your Symphony nº 1 in BM, sorry for the delay, crazy days!
I find it very personal and well structured, like the flute at around 3:00, and the violin around 5:50, and the increasing ostinato around 6:50....I like how the piece seems to flow with no effort, very nice work John!
At 7:35am on March 16, 2010, Yaiza Varona said…
Hi John !
Excuse the very tardy reply, I am busy as always. Just wanted to let you know I much appreciated all your comments on my work, and the time you took both to listen to my pieces and to write down your impressions.
Actually, I don´t know in what order you listened to them since I have my page here set up for random playing, the order in my album you can find in my webpage (actually it is just the order in which they were written).
About The Cat & the Hat, don´t worry the melody is original, built from editing some free loops. And the concert never took place! it is all an invention of mine, having fun with my computer :)
Thanks again for your time John, hope you are doing grand!
ps: big hug to your dog! :)
At 4:40pm on March 9, 2010, John Elliott said…
Oh, well thank you very much, then! In my world, "we" use the term "through line." (But people say I live there all by myself!)

At 4:33pm on March 9, 2010, Nemesis said…
Hey back!

"Red line" is my word creation :) It means that there is a structure in your score. On one hand the score seems self-contained. On other hand you put lots of emotion in it. So the result has quality AND entertaining.

Keep on moving
At 9:03am on March 9, 2010, Nemesis said…
Hi John,

I like the piano part in respect of "Seven Come Eight". Good score regarding the "red line" through the wohle execution.

Keep on moving
At 4:32pm on February 26, 2010, Christopher Sahar said…
Th eno comes from a 3 Cd collection called the early gurus of electronic music - 1948 - 1980
So I was mistaken covers a 32 year period but the composers highlighted span over 75 years considering their birth dates
At 5:47pm on February 13, 2010, Bethany Trainor said…
Hi John! Thanks for the friend request. Hmm...that is strange that is said I added 5 songs, but you only see four. Not sure why that is. Take care and I look forward to hearing more of your music!
At 2:54am on February 5, 2010, Yaiza Varona said…
Hi John, thanks so much for the deep review!
I am about to catch a fly, will be away for 10 days and don't know if I will be able to login in the forum while I'm away, but I promise to get back to you whenever is possible. Thanks again for all your attention, hope your doggie is better now!
Thanks again, take care
At 4:24pm on February 3, 2010, Yaiza Varona said…
Hi John!
I have been listening to your work, I especially liked Caprice and Still, found them very original. Of Still I particulary like the lightness of marimba? developement, sounds quite lively and fresh, and I like the contrast at about 3:10, gives new perspective to the piece. Very nice.
Regards, Yaiza
At 2:05pm on January 30, 2010, Chris Merritt said…
Hi John - There may have been some confusion about you needing an extra account deleted here. All should be fixed now... Sorry for the inconvenience!
At 3:24pm on December 9, 2009, Simon Godden said…
Hi John,

Chris Merritt has asked me to contact all existing compsers that have reserved slots on the above project. It has to be said that the World's Longest Piece is gathering the momentum it needs now, which is great news. So can you inform Chris how near you are to finishing your piece, as I believe that he is anxious to get to work blending/mastering them into one sigle unit. We're gonna hit the big time!! Whoopee!!!


At 2:59am on December 8, 2009, Asevenc said…
I would love it if you went through my music and left your feedback.
I am trying to work towards being a composer, but unfortunately, I cannot read music, as I have never learnt any. Do you have any suggestions as to where I can learn sheet music ? Any website ? I am listening to your tracks again. I like your individuality. It's really sad you don't plan to take this up professionally.
At 3:51pm on December 7, 2009, John Elliott said…
A PDF of the first page of "Seven Come Eight" can be found at
At 3:45pm on December 7, 2009, John Elliott said…
About "Seven Come Eight":

Composed 12-13 July (initial notes, ideas, melody & basic harmonic structure), and 28-30 November to 8 December 2006.

The challenge: write a piece in 7|8. I started by assuming that "seven-eight" was applicable to more than just the time signature. I played around with the numbers themselves.

I worked out the bulk of the structural elements for this piece. First: Rhythm. I determined that the internal rhythm of each measure was going to be 2+2+3 (but of course, there are some exceptions for variety; for examples: the opening section has the LH playing 3+2+2; there are also times when the RH will play 2+2+3 while the LH plays 3+2+2). Second: Key (~s). I started at C Major on the circle of fifths and went three key signatures in one direction to the key of Eb Major/c minor; then going four keys in the opposite direction (again from C), I came to E Major/c# minor. Three + four = seven. Silly, but that's where I started. I then decided to compose the RH in Eb Major and the LH in E Major. Third: Melody. Once the decision about keys was reached, I looked for the tones (notes) that the two keys had in common (c, d#/e-flat, g#/a-flat, a, b, b-flat), & decided to make my principal theme out of those notes. The principal theme places the notes in this order: c, e-flat, a, b, b-flat, c-flat, e-flat, b, b-flat, a, e-flat, a-flat, c, a, b-flat, a-flat. The theme is jagged and anxiouswith a strong forward-moving feel. Fourth: Instrumentation. Perhaps the easiest decision at first. I decided on the piano-but wanted to limit the range from the standard eighty-eight keys down to seventy-eight. When I took off the top and bottom five keys, I was left with the lowest c and the highest a-flat on the piano. Ironically, these notes were the first and last notes of the principal theme I had already written. I started by calling it simply "78" (for obvious reasons). And that lead to a play on the phrase "7 come 11."

At 3:14pm on December 7, 2009, Asevenc said…
Very unusual.
Liking 7 come 8.
What are your inspirations ?

Sign up info

Read before you sign up to find out what the requirements are!


© 2020   Created by Gav Brown.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service