Timothy Smith replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"Thank you Mineso,
I tend to be heavy handed in my own mastering techniques and as you likely are aware, a master especially a master 30 minutes long will have many peaks and many low volume areas scattered throughout. Mastering for the best overall…"
Dec 18, 2021
Minseo Park replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"First of all, thank you very much for your detailed comment.  I took a look at the loudness level from Cubase and it is about -20 LUFS (integrated).   In addition, the loudness level for the initial part of the music (quiet passage) is even lower…"
Dec 18, 2021
David Owen replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"I don't think it's a problem, it's just that for my taste the device is a bit crude compared to the beauty of a good deal of the rest of the score. You are perfectly entitled to disagree with my assessment.
 "
Dec 15, 2021
Timothy Smith replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"I agree applying the EWQL techniques to classical music is not a good thing. The LUFS standards are what mixing engineers use to gauge the volume of any particular genre. In that sense it really isn't extremely subjective. -20--16 LUFS is the…"
Dec 15, 2021
Timothy Smith replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"Mineso, Were you between -20 and -16 LUFS?  If you are maybe the issue is on my end. For most tracks I play in the classical genre I can comfortably hear them at 50% volume. At 60-75% volume it sounds like I'm in the audience in a real concert in…"
Dec 15, 2021
Minseo Park replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"First of all, thank you very much for your comments!!!  For my defense, I just wanted to let you know that the harp-sounding tunes you mentioned was not intended to be the ones played by a real "acoustic" harp.  It will be nearly impossible for an…"
Dec 14, 2021
Minseo Park replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"I appreciate your valuable comments!  I will take a look at the "voices" problem you mentioned.  Best regards,"
Dec 14, 2021
Minseo Park replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"The volume level looked OK to me.  I do not know what the problem is.  Anyway, thank you very much for your comment!!!  Cheers!"
Dec 14, 2021
Minseo Park replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"Thank you very much for your comments!  I will check the mixing part."
Dec 14, 2021
Dane Aubrun replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"A very long listen!
An accomplished composition and congratulations at putting together a work of this length.
I can sense where Tim's coming from about the film music if he had to break at 15 mins. The voices made me think the same - and there's…"
Dec 13, 2021
David Owen replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"I think this is certainly more subtle and intelligent than most cinematic music and I'm glad I discovered it. The main thing that lets it down for me is the rather crude use of voices, particularly near the end. The rendering is more than loud…"
Dec 13, 2021
Timothy Smith replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"I listened to about 15 minutes of this and for lack of time could not continue. This would be A+ cinematic music, however it lacks enough volume to hear very well without turning the volume to the extreme.
The music itself is well composed and mixed…"
Dec 13, 2021
Rowy van Hest replied to Minseo Park's discussion Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju Island
"I like your music, it makes me feel positiv although the weather here is miserable. The mix could do with a bit of work. Perhaps not right at once, but after a while. In the beginning the flute sounds rather weak in relation to the rest of the…"
Dec 13, 2021
Minseo Park posted a discussion
Hi all,I would like to share with you my orchestral composition.  YouTube link is as follows;Symphonic Poem: Rhapsody on the Shore of Jeju IslandThanks for your attention!Minseo Park
Dec 12, 2021
Minseo Park replied to Minseo Park's discussion An Odyssey to Mars (Original Composition)
"Hi, H. S.,
Thank you very much for your comments! 
Video was added to the music after the composition, not the other way around. 
I was also thinking about making the ending part longer, but decided not to do that since the piece is already long. …"
Sep 2, 2021
H. S. Teoh replied to Minseo Park's discussion An Odyssey to Mars (Original Composition)
"Wow, this is a long one. Hard to comment in detail because of the length. Overall, great orchestration and captivating music. Quite moving in some parts. Was this composed independently and the video added afterwards, or was the music conceived with…"
Sep 1, 2021
More…

Comment Wall

You need to be a member of Composers' Forum to add comments!

Join Composers' Forum

Comments

  • Greetings Minseo,

    I like your music very much. Thanks for sharing.

    Very best,

    Larry Elliott

  • You are Wonderful composer !!! Congratultations

  • A sojourn in paradise is a very attractive piece, I like your open melodic architecture ....Regards.
  • I too like CompuMuze!  I also like Bassoon Dream, but it would be more effective with a softer version of the piano. (not volume, but tone)
  • Hey =] I really like CompuMaze and the Conquest of Agony,  especially the bass lines.
  • my pleasure
  • Very nice Music. I am a math teacher and you can't have science without math.
  • Hey man, I got inspired by your fugue and decided to use your cool youtube idea and put it there. Here's the link:

    https://composersforum.ning.com/forum/topics/piano-quintet-4-voice-f...

     

     

    Piano Quintet. 4 Voice Fugue in the style of Astor Piazzolla
    Here's another Piano Quintet in the style of one of my favorites composers, Astor Piazzolla.   It's a fugue 4 voice fugue with accompaniment.   http:…
  • Hello Minseo and welcome! What kind of science do you do?
This reply was deleted.