Josip Gracin replied to Alexey Arkhipenko's discussion [HOW-TO] Creating sample-based orchestral arrangements
"Great tutorial! Thanks!"
Jul 30, 2013
Gordon Francis Blaney Jr. replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"Version of Sibelius? (I can save the files in whatever version you've got, then I can send it via this forum or personal e-mail, then you can write in the remaining parts without hassle, lastly you can post it on the forum for feedback from various…"
Sep 12, 2012
Josip Gracin replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"Hi, Gordon!  Thanks, I'd appreciate that!"
Sep 12, 2012
Gordon Francis Blaney Jr. replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"I know I promised to post a realization of the roman numerals with the given bass: I, however, after careful inspection would suggest learning to write melodies, then learn to write a bass line utilizing the exact techniques for writing melodies,…"
Sep 12, 2012
Gordon Francis Blaney Jr. replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"As soon as I get to my office, I'll re-realize this example and re-post it for benefit of learning four-part voice leading, because: "A note is worth a thousand words"."
Sep 11, 2012
Josip Gracin replied to Gavin Brown's discussion Must it be new?
"Hi, Bob!

Bob Porter said:
I'm confused by many of your statements.



Really?  Which ones?

Have you written any music, regardless of how good you may think it is?



Well, yes.  Very few, though.  Currently, I'm mostly entertaining myself by…"
Aug 4, 2012
Josip Gracin replied to Gavin Brown's discussion Must it be new?
"I'm not (yet?) a composer so I really might be talking nonsense here.I believe that listening and composing are entirely different perspectiveson music.  Writing a decent symphony in, for example, classical style (asin "Mozartian") requires years of…"
Aug 3, 2012
Josip Gracin replied to Gavin Brown's discussion Must it be new?
"My guess is that by the time one reaches skill and maturity to composesomething comparable to Mozart's symphonies, he/she realizes that it'simpossible to produce something interesting within the confines of musicalvocabulary used in such…"
Aug 3, 2012
Josip Gracin replied to Gavin Brown's discussion Must it be new?
"Here are some thoughts, largely in agreement with what Don has written acouple of posts above.Every individual strives to create things she/he can be proud of.  Everycomposition a composer is proud of contains some things (aspects) which…"
Aug 1, 2012
Josip Gracin replied to Ariel Ramos's discussion Piano Trio (Violin, Cello and Piano)
"Oops, I can't download it either.  Getting 404 Not Found."
Aug 21, 2011
Josip Gracin replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"Anne, Spyrus, Vlad, thank you all for your time and effort!  I find your remarks very useful.  I could ask some further questions but I'll hold until I've re-examined all that you've written.
Cheers!"
Aug 1, 2011
Vlad Burlea replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"Spyrus, sorry, I didnt see the "key word" NOT GOOD! in your replay.
Josip, Spyrus is right in all his long replay, read once more carefully his recommendations and go ahead! 
Success!"
Aug 1, 2011
Vlad Burlea replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"No this is not mistake but not interesting, better to move B in bass to D# (halfe notes ) D# the same to B tie to next,  B in tenor jump to G (later, get down to A  and go to G ).

SpyrusTheVirus said:
as I said, "One, not good for the ending chord,…"
Jul 31, 2011
Spiros Makris replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"as I said, "One, not good for the ending chord, solution is for the Soprano to go to G and the Alto to B in ms 10 and 11, and you will have a full chord." :D unless you were just underlying my point. 
 
In Anne's solution I see a leading note (D#)…"
Jul 31, 2011
Vlad Burlea replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"Hi, Josip. You progression is good like exercise, no cross voice and the distance in positions is good. By the way, have to keep the distance between tenor, alto, and soprano, but between bass and other can be reasonably large. You have one mistake…"
Jul 31, 2011
Spiros Makris replied to Josip Gracin's discussion Elementary harmony question -- voice leading
"I think Anne missed the little "8" under the Tenor Clef-I did too at first, until I read your post. I learned 4 part harmony in  2 staff system and I find it more convenient- I don't know what Schoenberg suggests, but you should give it a try. 2…"
Jul 31, 2011
More…

Comment Wall

You need to be a member of Composers' Forum to add comments!

Join Composers' Forum

Comments

  • Welcome to the Composers' Forum

    Could you please include the biographical information you sent me to your own page here. Thanks in advance

    -Tyler

    Admin

This reply was deleted.