H. S. Teoh replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"@Ingo: why bother telling his ears what to think, if they truly find the sounds "ghastly and horrid"? It's not as though there is an objective measure of how "horrible" a sound is perceived by some random listener."
Jun 23, 2017
Ingo Lee replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"@ Mr. Zarb-Cousin
There are many things on this earth that are "ghastly and horrid" but I promise you none of them are sounds coming out of speakers or headphones.
When you do encounter things that are truly "ghastly and horrid", what words will you…"
Jun 23, 2017
Bob Morabito replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"Rowy--no one is being offensive, at least not me..its a shame youre taking it that way, as it isnt intended.
I took your saying about "growing up and destroying the modern stuff"--as a joke--and joked back about it. But we really should end this…"
Jun 23, 2017
Rowy van Hest replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"And now you're being offensive. The more I was praised for my so called modern work, the more I wanted to destroy it and so I did. It was nothing more than "interesting" music and even as a young composer I knew that this kind of music is the…"
Jun 23, 2017
Bob Morabito replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"I couldnt agree more H.S.-thanks :)
Thanks Bob https://soundcloud.com/bob-morabito H. S. Teoh said:
Bob Morabito said:
[...] Write what you feel, and stand by it.



Hi Bob, just wanted say that despite all the things we disagree on, this is spot…"
Jun 23, 2017
Bob Morabito replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"+1
Thanks Bob https://soundcloud.com/bob-morabito Mike Hewer said:
Great post Socrates and a priceless link."
Jun 23, 2017
H. S. Teoh replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"Bob Morabito said:
[...] Write what you feel, and stand by it.



Hi Bob, just wanted say that despite all the things we disagree on, this is spot on. Composers should be sincere and write what they feel, rather than what they think others would…"
Jun 23, 2017
Bob Morabito replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"Hi Daniel-
I dont take it that way--simply that they find it interesting, or different. And I find it MUCH better to not think one has failed because of others opinions. Write what you feel, and stand by it.
Thanks Bob…"
Jun 23, 2017
Bob Morabito replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"I already said that it also does affect me, but that I do spend hours each and every day to listening to newly composed music of all genres. So I am still hearing a broad spectrum of whats out there, of all kinds, and perhaps you might do the same…"
Jun 23, 2017
Socrates Arvanitakis replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"Mike Hewer said:



 The Morris is an excellent read and full of music from the literature rather than isolated footballs in 2 parts."
Jun 23, 2017
Rowy van Hest replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"I'm almost afraid to listen to your music now :-) Daniel Zarb-Cousin said:
"It's very... interesting" is code for "I don't feel at all taken by it."  If the first thing people say about my music is that it is "interesting" or "different" to them, I…"
Jun 23, 2017
Rowy van Hest replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"The subsidized part Ive read and am familiar with (IRCAM)  but I honestly really do find it hard to believe that the younger generation prefers to write tonal music.
They do and it's not my fault, because I couldn't care less :-)
I think this…"
Jun 23, 2017
Mike Hewer replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"Great post Socrates and a priceless link. My training in early polyphony came via Contrapuntal technique in the 16 thc by R.O.Morris.
which was a less pedantic book than the species book by Swindon I also ploughed through. The Morris is an excellent…"
Jun 23, 2017
Daniel Zarb-Cousin replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
""It's very... interesting" is code for "I don't feel at all taken by it."  If the first thing people say about my music is that it is "interesting" or "different" to them, I will feel as though I have failed.   Rowy van Hest said:
> decadent…"
Jun 23, 2017
Socrates Arvanitakis replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"Hi Amol,
a reply just on J. J. Fux
 
Fux wrote his book as a kind of instruction on composition. He came up with the idea of species counterpoint though, as a didactic method. So far so good, but there it is in the outset of his concept the first…"
Jun 23, 2017
Bob Morabito replied to Amol's discussion Please help me understand Beethoven (or counterpoint in general)
"Thanks, Dave-- much appreciated.
Thanks Bob https://soundcloud.com/bob-morabito Dave Dexter said:
I think we've established your style isn't to my preference, but I thought I'd tip my respect hat your way for essentially not giving a shit or…"
Jun 23, 2017
More…