Replies

  • Wow! This is absolutly beautiful with so many melodic and harmonic surprises. Sooo delightful to listen to!!! But I would not call it Scherzo ...
    Gerd
  • There are some really nice and beautiful moment in the piece.

    But the problem is the length, also somewhat repetitious, where the repeated right hand notes can be tedious.

    Also sounding somewhat Beethovenian is not a problem, but overdoing it can be a distraction. 

    I would shorten the piece to no more then 6 or 7 minutes. 

    Regards

  •  

    I enjoyed most of this. Not sure if it was the dynamics or the piano sound. It seems to me the 8th note runs are almost too dynamic. The dadadada section where the note remains in one place. 

    Amazing work though and must have taken a long time and a lot of work to complete it. Kudos!

This reply was deleted.