Replies

  • I like it, reminds me of Einaudi or Glass.  It's repetitive in the modern style, with enough change to keep the listener interested.  I'd like to hear more.


  • Thanks for the feedback. Any ideas on what to add? Should I Add new material at the end so that it's something like an ABACA pattern? (B being most of the song)
    Alan MacRae said:

    I like it, reminds me of Einaudi or Glass.  It's repetitive in the modern style, with enough change to keep the listener interested.  I'd like to hear more.

    Piano Orchestral - The Dissimulated Void
    What do you think of this music I wrote? It is a film-style piano/orchestral piece. I used a free piano VST and Sonatina Symphonic Orchestra for the…
  • If you want to extend it in time, you could easily add a repeat of the A theme first time, so you'd have AABA, where the convention would probably look for some slight change to the theme after the B, so A-A-B-A'.  The addition of a whole new theme would also work, ABACA as you suggest, again with a slight change to the cyclic theme, or as is, rondo form. 

    For me, personally, I don't like too many themes is a single movement of a larger piece, like a suite or symphony, but it works well in a single movement structure, so my thoughts would depend on your further intentions for this piece - will it be a part of something larger? 

    I think your B theme is sufficiently different not to appear a variation on A, and something like sonata form may work here.  Nice exposition, now work on the development.

    Good luck with it.

    Alan

  • Totally agree with Alan. And I really like your work !

  • I greatly appreciate all the meaningful feedback ;-). Especially everything on soundcloud. This will not be part of anything larger. So it sounds like it would be best to stick to a structure close to rondo form. I was thinking of modulating back into the original key in part C.

    Alan MacRae said:

    If you want to extend it in time, you could easily add a repeat of the A theme first time, so you'd have AABA, where the convention would probably look for some slight change to the theme after the B, so A-A-B-A'.  The addition of a whole new theme would also work, ABACA as you suggest, again with a slight change to the cyclic theme, or as is, rondo form. 

    For me, personally, I don't like too many themes is a single movement of a larger piece, like a suite or symphony, but it works well in a single movement structure, so my thoughts would depend on your further intentions for this piece - will it be a part of something larger? 

    I think your B theme is sufficiently different not to appear a variation on A, and something like sonata form may work here.  Nice exposition, now work on the development.

    Good luck with it.

    Alan

    Piano Orchestral - The Dissimulated Void
    What do you think of this music I wrote? It is a film-style piano/orchestral piece. I used a free piano VST and Sonatina Symphonic Orchestra for the…
This reply was deleted.