Choral Symphonic Idea

Hi Everyone,

[edit - oh what the hell - I'll put both movements up for now]

Was interested to get a preliminary dissection on this....

They are also on my composer profile page

...and on my twitter and facebook and and my website and on...... ;)

You need to be a member of Composers' Forum to add comments!

Join Composers' Forum

Email me when people reply –


  • Thanks Zach....I know what you mean - I've had a funny relationship with this movement and realise the the harp pattern is possibly not going to carry the piece without some help. I also wonder if the choir will take away from this if ever performed live. There is also a possible soprano top line to embellish the other melodies and you mention this as an extra dimension - which I agree the piece needs.

    Actually - I should say - I only call this a symphonic idea - with so much choir it is possibly an oratorio - but thought some initial feedback in this instance would be useful so thank you for listening so freely and given me such an insightful perspective.

    The struggle I face (enjoyable though) is to make the music seem natural and long.

    In the second part I will turn the reverb down a bit - it seemed to come up a bit when I mastered it.

    Thanks again Zach.

    J - This website is for sale! - long Resources and Information.
    This website is for sale! is your first and best source for all of the information you’re looking for. From general topics to more of what yo…
  • hmmm - abandoned I think. Sadly. I am still fond of it but it just doesn't seem to carry the drama along.

    Maybe I just need a few weeks away from it.
This reply was deleted.