Composers' Forum

Music Composers Unite!

Paul Mitchell-Davidson's Comments

Comment Wall (15 comments)

You need to be a member of Composers' Forum to add comments!

Join Composers' Forum

At 8:30pm on August 24, 2011, Paulo cesar Maia de Aguiar (Br) said…
Amaizng Works
At 12:45pm on October 4, 2010, Tombo Rombo said…

Wowza. It is great to have somebody as obviously accomplished as you here. Listening to "The Galloping Cat". I love the complicated unison horn runs and I imagine that is you playing the guitar? I'm not worthy!!


At 4:31pm on August 29, 2010, Andrew Gleibman said…
Thank you for so warm feedback and comments Paul! There are not too many improvisers out there, and I immediately recognized the improvisation origin in your compositions. Now I am trying to reach the impossible - to mimic a live orchestra using a keyboard-based instrument (now I apply 2 keyboards). Using a music box like Finale or Sibelius, based on conventional notation, this is impossible however good are sampled instruments. Only live performance allows one to express the real given-moment emotion, and for me this process is much more interesting than the cold-minded process of music writing.
At 4:05pm on August 29, 2010, Adrian Allan said…
Thanks so much for your kind comments - it means a lot from somebody with your wealth of experience. My friend Mark Kelly used to be in your guitar orchestra - you may not remember him, but he sends his best wishes.


At 2:03pm on August 23, 2010, Andrew Gleibman said…
Great music Paul! Simon Godden has kindly alerted me about your uploaded tracks, and I find your atonal language and instrument combinations highly expressive. I would be glad if you take a listen to my atonal improvisations and provide me with some feedback...
At 9:03am on August 23, 2010, Adrian Allan said…
Hi Paul

Try Youtube in 2 parts

part 1

part 2

If all else fails I'll giev you a link to the audio only


At 7:38am on August 22, 2010, Simon Godden said…
Hi Paul,

Thanks for alerting me to the music you've just posted up on your site. I absolutely adore "Threnody". It's extremely moving and displays an enormous amount of emotion and feeling. I feel that anybody that experiments with pantonality MUST first learn to tackle all aspects of key based music first, otherwise I find their atonal music a bit careless. In 'Threnody', you've managed to explore extremely opposing genres and blended them with a huge amount of skill. Who would have thought it possible to have an atonal string quartet playing simultaneously with a jazz combo, and live instruments as well. It really is quite a masterpiece, and I shall be listening to it regularly.

My only despair is that you may find my music a touch on the crass side.

Thanks again for posting. I really did enjoy it.
At 7:28am on August 22, 2010, Adrian Allan said…
Hi Paul

Thanks for showing an interest.

The links are still active on THIS page - just three posts down. Click on them for the video and the sibelius score.

If you don't have sibelius scorch the PDF is also here

thanks again

At 4:13pm on August 7, 2010, Adrian Allan said…
Hello Paul

I've been in the Isle of Man for a week, so I missed your last message. I would like to help you on the subject of the Chinese Writing, but you're best asking one of the admins of this site (on the home page), who can delve deeper into such issues.

I have enjoyed listening to your music, and it's great to hear something that is really performed live, as most music here is by "virtual instruments".

I know that you usually get paid to give advice on composition, so I just asked you as a small favour to take a quick listen to my piece - the added interest is that it's about Manchester. So if you ever do, I'd be more than grateful.

Best wishes

At 3:48pm on July 29, 2010, Simon Godden said…
I'd like that. My e-mail address is:
At 2:57pm on July 29, 2010, Adrian Allan said…
sorry, those links are not showing up

If you add me as a friend I will send them in a message

or copy and paste these links into browser


At 2:54pm on July 29, 2010, Adrian Allan said…
Thanks Paul for comment.

I heard Craig Ogden play your guitar piece at St Annes Church in 1993 and approached him afterwards for guitar lessons. Unlike most guitarists he is a true musician - a force to be reckoned with; he also has an amazing rhythmic accuracy. He will do your concerto justice when he plays it; a professional in every sense.

I don't know if you know the story of Angel Meadow in Manchester, a corner of the city near the CIS building where there is still a "ragged school" building where the poor children were given a very basic education.

Well, I wrote a symphonic poem based upon the life and struggles of those people. I will post you a link to the discussion , where I present the music PDF (done on Sibelius) and an mp3 digital mock-up. I also did a video to visually represent the music.

I would be really grateful if you could have a quick look/ listen as I would have a lot to learn from sombody of your experience.

The score is here. Please click on play mp3

The video is here

thanks again for your time

At 12:58pm on July 28, 2010, Simon Godden said…
Hi Paul, welcome to the forum. I look forward to hearing some of your work. Please feel free to listen to any of mine. I eat constructive criticism in order to stay alive. Like Adrian, I am also struggling to be a composer (as opposed to a producer). Indeed, one or two of my works ("Alphabet Green" and "Flanders" in particular) were written with pen and paper during my studies at Queens University Belfast, sometimes without access to a piano. However, it's difficult to get people to listen to it now unless the production is half decent, which is a shame. There are few people that can read a score and hear the music, but they are wonderful people to know.
At 11:30am on July 25, 2010, Adrian Allan said…
Hi Paul thanks for the comments. I've heard about you for a long time - I'm a Mancunian classical guitarist too and studied with Martin Roberts and Craig Ogden. I have since turned to composition, though, but still teach guitar a little in Manchester. I hope you are enjoying your new life and Portugal and thanks again for the listen.
At 2:12am on July 25, 2010, Adrian Allan said…
Welcome to composers' forum; if you get the chance please check out my Nonet which features classical guitar and is on the main page of this forum under "discussions".

Sign up info

Read before you sign up to find out what the requirements are!


© 2021   Created by Gav Brown.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service