Music Composers Unite!
We're sorry, but this discussion has just been closed to further replies.
Tags:
Unfortunately Per, I've nothing to say in the way of constructive or instructive thoughts, but I enjoyed it very much. This and your last piece has me noticing and looking forward to your music. Very uplifting music.
Very beautiful... sweeping and epic. It reminds me in many places of Aaron Copland's "Appalachian Spring" (which remains one of my favorite pieces of all time), in the blend of mellow, pastoral sections, and charged crescendo points. Excellent work!
If any critique at all I would offer is that your string attacks are a bit strong in some parts, but that really is a minor point.
If you are looking for a constructive critique, here it is. First, you slightly overuse the sol major key. May be it is worth to unexpectedly alter this somewhere to la-bemol major and then return, or even alter once more a semiton up. Second, there is not a distinctive culmination of the piece, which (I feel) should be somewhere near 3:30. I would even add some unexpected distinctive pauses in order to break the rhythm. Then, the theme si-la-sol at 2:45 and 3:01 would sound better in violin solo. At last, the end of the piece is slightly odd; some more developed cadenza is expected here.
© 2009 Created by Chris Merritt on Ning. Create a Ning Network!