Composers' Forum

Music Composers Unite!

Hi All,

Old time Logic user (since the Notator and Creator days), just had my PC Logic 5.5.1 system die and figured I might as well finally bite the bullet and get a Mac. BUT, I'm second guessing that decision. I could fix my PC and migrate to CuBase or FL Studio. So here are the pros and cons as I see them.

Pros:

1. Logic X will be able to load my existing files as native. There will be plenty of adjusting necessary (plug-ins, instruments, automation), but the basic music (midi data) will be there.

2. Logic X is an industry standard and represents incredible value for a modest investment.

3. Basic familiarity with the underlying structure should ease the learning curve a little.

Cons:

1. I'll have to buy a Mac, Macs are great systems, but they're not the most cost effective alternative.

2. The only plug-ins I'll have to start will be those that come with the software, all VST plug-ins will be unusable.

3. My complete unfamiliarity with the Mac universe.

In addition. I have a M-Audio Midisport 8x8 and their legacy drivers section does show drivers up to Mac OS 10.12. Am I screwed (need to get new midi interface) or is this workable with a new Mac? I know I'll need a new audio interface, I've had good luck with the Focusrite Scarlett series. I also use Midi over LAN CP3 to move midi data to a sample machine (PC) running Kontakt and some other stuff (Garritan CFX, Kirk Hunter Strings).

To start I anticipate most of the samples I'll use will be played on the existing PC. Also, in the PC world it was recommended to use a separate drive for audio, is that still the case in the Mac world or have machines gotten so fast disk issues are a thing of the past? Or should I just get a USB drive and back up my work? Will 8 GB of RAM be enough or should I just get 16 GB? It seems these days any hard drive has more than enough real estate for my needs, but I know solid state drives are way faster than disks.

Your thoughts please?

Views: 180

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Hi Ray,

If I'm considering buying a Mac then I'm considering making a significant investment. Buying a Windows machine would allow some savings on the hardware side and going to CuBase would allow me to continue using VST plug-ins. I used an RME interface card in one of my systems. The RME Babyface Pro would solve the midi I/O challenge, but negate some of the savings. My M-Audio Midisport 8x8 has a Windows 10 driver and the Scarlett would be much less than the RME as an audio interface.

Bob,

Do I understand your recommendation is also to stay on Windows. Look forward to your more detailed response.

Steve

For myself I cant recommend getting a Mac highly enough. Ive used them since they first came out, and am completely satisfied, and so are all of those who Ive recommended it who switched--not only for the computer, OS. etc, but for the Applecare extended warranty, which in NY here or at least in my case, they come to my home and make repairs here, same day, ready to go.Id look into this Applecare wherever you are to see if they provide home service where you are.https://www.apple.com/support/products/mac.html

Don't let others in this thread try and scare you away from Apple, or take my recommendation for it..try them and see for yourself :)

Good luck in whatever you buy!

Thanks Bob https://soundcloud.com/bob-morabito

I own both PC and Mac and they both can either work fine or drive you crazy with issues.  You do not have to go far to find someone who will complain or brag about either one.

Yes to lots and lots of RAM and yes to an SSD.  Back up several times, at least one of which should be off site if your files mean anything at all. Check the compatibility issues carefully and use trial versions of stuff as much as possible, try and shop at places that have a liberal return policy.

Cubase Pro user on Windows here.  Runs like a charm.  Mac is overpriced hooey IMHO. 

Okay, so I priced a current MacBook Pro with a 2.9 GHz quad-core i7 processor, 512 GB SSD drive, 16 GB RAM and it was $2800, plus $200 for Logic. There was no option to add additional memory. I've been informed that a refurbed 15" MacBook (last generation) would be $1500 or $1800 (she wasn't sure), and she didn't know the specs (well meaning, but not tech savvy girlfriend). Finally, I looked at an iMac 27" screen, 4.2 GHz quad-core i7, with 32GB RAM and a 512 GB SSD drive with Logic X and it weighs in at $3500.

CuBase is $579, and here's what I could get from Dell, 27" all in one (like iMac), with i7-7700 3.6 GHz quad-core processor, 32 GB RAM (non ECC), two SSD drives one 256 GB the 2nd 360 GB for $2658.47.

Or I could replace the crashed drive in my WinXP system, keep Logic 5.5.1 alive a little longer and start saving.

FYI, I won't be putting everything in one box anytime soon. I am sentimental about Logic. I've been using it for decades, but Apple isn't Emagic. I would like to avail myself of all the goodies in Logic X.

One last thing, the guy at the Apple store told me I should get 4 GB vs 2 GB of video memory. Frankly, unless you're putting sound to video I can't see why Logic would need high end graphics (and even then it's doubtful).

If you get a Mac you might think about getting a 2010 3.33GHz or 3.46GHz 12-core used Mac Pro. They are roughly around $1500 on and a bit more from online sellers like OWC and ibuildmacs.com. It sounds like you haven't been needing the latest and greatest hardware or software. This Mac is just about as efficient with Logic Pro X as Apple's current TOTL 12-core trash can Mac Pro. It's known to be compatible with up to macOS High Sierra which will be released this fall and the latest Logic Pro X and probably a few more updates. Installing a flashed for Mac 2GB GTX 680 you can use a 40" to 43" 4K display. The come standard ATI Radeon 5770 will work with up to two 30"displays at 2560X1600 resolution. You'll have 4 standard 3.5  drive bays plus options for a few PCIe slot drive cards (these will be recognized as external drives) and also you can use the optical drive bays for up to two more drives. I have eight drives in mine which include Windows 7 using Apples Bootcamp. It is also possible to boot into Widows 10, not using Bootcamp, with the proper technical knowledge.

 

Hi Phillip,

Thank you for the thoughts, that is probably the most useful post I've received on multiple forums. Having been a PC guy my knowledge of the Mac world is woefully lacking. What I really wanted was a system that could open my existing Logic files without having to try to reconstruct them. They are Logic songs not midi files so migrating to another software to stay on Windows would be difficult or impossible and probably require resurrecting my existing system with a new hard drive just to export midi files. Apple says Logic X will load Logic 5 songs so I'm good there.

Just so you know, I'm coming from a computer that was a single core AMD processor running at maybe 2 GHz and had 1 GB of RAM (hence second PC for samples). Any multi core processor with 16 GB of RAM or more will be able to run rings around it. While processors haven't gotten that much faster the execution of code with larger cache and multiple cores allows current processors to outperform the old ones by orders of magnitude. Having said that I'll bet Logic X is probably 10x the code as Logic 5, but is presumably well coded for multi-threading (using multiple cores) so I'd still expect it to perform like a rocket. I expect even a 7 year old system such as you described will be able to load anything I've done and do much more with it. I don't need a 4K display, but obviously VGA (what Windows uses) need not apply. I'm sure a smaller HDTV will do the job.

So I found an 8 core 2.4 GHz Mac Pro with 16 GB of RAM and 1 TB 7200 RPM drive. I'm sure one of the first things I would do would be add a SSD drive. It can be upgraded to Mac OS 10.12, but I'm not sure why that would be important other than it could run the current version of Logic. Can the current version of Logic run on Mac OS 10.6.8? That system weighs in at $1600, but that's a lot easier than what I've been looking at.

>Can the current version of Logic run on Mac OS 10.6.8?

I really dont know anything about Logic but found this:

https://www.apple.com/logic-pro/specs/

Minimum System Requirements
  • 4GB of RAM
  • Display with 1280-by-768 resolution or higher
  • OS X 10.11 or later
  • Requires 64-bit Audio Units plug-ins
  • Minimum 6GB of disk space. 51GB of optional content available via in-app download.

https://support.apple.com/kb/SP673?locale=en_US

Logic Pro 9 - Technical Specifications

Minimum System Requirements

  • 2GB of RAM (4GB recommended).
  • Display with 1280-by-768 resolution or higher.
  • OS X v10.6.8 or later.
  • Minimum 6GB of disk space. (19GB of optional content available via in-app download).
  • Thanks Bob https://soundcloud.com/bob-morabito

Hi Steve,  Apple no longer supports OS X 10.6.8, which can be problem. Also, older hardware versions don't except OS X upgrades past a certain point so you'd have to check that too.

Steve Chandler said:

. It can be upgraded to Mac OS 10.12, but I'm not sure why that would be important other than it could run the current version of Logic. Can the current version of Logic run on Mac OS 10.6.8? That system weighs in at $1600, but that's a lot easier than what I've been looking at.

On the Logic Users Group I see the latest version of Logic Pro 10.3.2 requires Mac OS 10.11. Obviously the upgrade path of an older Mac is fairly limited, however that concerns me less (right now) because I know Logic Pro X will have a steep learning curve and substantially greater capability than Logic 5. It'll probably take me a few years to get fully acclimated to it and by that time I might be ready to upgrade to a then current Mac or I may be perfectly happy with it. I wasn't unhappy with Logic 5, but I was unable to get current plug-ins and the only upgrade path was to migrate to a Mac. Now that's simply necessary, so I'm saving my pennies, and in time will bite the bullet and do it.

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Sign up info

Read before you sign up to find out what the requirements are!

Store

© 2018   Created by Gav Brown.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service