Music Composers Unite!
these are the first four measures of a piece I'm writing in D major. the fourth measure ends in a new tonic B I havent been able to make it work in harmony it doesnt sound right. can someone give it a try?
Tags:
Permalink Reply by Clark Nichols on November 25, 2011 at 5:54pm
Permalink Reply by Spiros Makris on November 27, 2011 at 1:23pm start by writting in 4 parts, and post the finale file of the melody line you are trying to harmonize, that way we can offer more help. :P
Permalink Reply by Greg Brus on November 27, 2011 at 2:44pm The 3rd measure harmonised as follows:
1 2 3 4
D/A Bm Em Em/C#
should be enough. Is it supposed to be a solo violin piece? Modulations for violin alone are kinda tricky, especially such rapid ones. There's also the question of whether you want the sudden increase of tension created by many chords in a single measure to be present at all.
Permalink Reply by Gordon Francis Blaney Jr. on September 11, 2012 at 1:56am D major isn't established in a convincing manner: G major, however, is. B minor can't be established in a convincing manner in this particular situation without proper preparation and resolution. Whilst I'd agree that B minor can be established with or without preparation: in a situation where B minor is establish without preparation, the passage would be most success if continued. I'd be glad to attach a file later --- when I'm at my work desk.
Permalink Reply by Gordon Francis Blaney Jr. on September 11, 2012 at 10:45pm I hope the attached file might assist in generating some ideas.
Permalink Reply by Michael Edwards on December 3, 2012 at 1:08am Hallo - I'm new here, and I'm not sure yet whether I'm meant to formally introduce myself to the forum, and where.
But it seems to me I'd need to know a bit more about this before I could really offer an opinion. For instance, is this an unaccompanied violin piece, or the violin part in a piece for two or more instruments? I think whether this is the entire texture of the music or not would make a big difference. And, when you say you haven't been able to make "work in harmony", does that imply that you intend to add further harmonic parts (presumably in other instruments) that are not shown in the score you posted?
Why exactly don't you think this works? I couldn't put my finger on anything wrong with it, and the modulation to B major seems okay to me. But of course if you don't think it's right, then that's what counts. And a lot might also depend on what happens next, after the modulation to B major.
Hope this helps a tiny bit. I might be able to suggest more with a bit more detailed information.
Regards, Michael Edwards.
Permalink Reply by Dust Composer (Ronald Hutasuhut) on December 3, 2012 at 6:44am I'm not sure the score is fit with Violin duet, separated staff would be better.
© 2013 Created by Chris Merritt.