Composers' Forum

Music Composers Unite!

The Music Debate Forum (116)

Discussions Replies Latest Activity

Music Titles and "The Waltz"

After a comment that one of my pieces entitled a waltz, did not sound like a waltz to one member listener, i had a really fascinating discu…

Started by Suzanne Munro

21 Feb 13
Reply by Sahir Haider

About melody and rythm

Is there a secret to give the rythm of a melody an "objective"(or more of this characteristic) to make the music less relying on harmony?

Started by Lucas Oliveira Krumenaur

16 Jun 18, 2019
Reply by Lucas Oliveira Krumenaur

How can we define music?

The question has come up many times here as to what is music. Isn't that questioned answered by what you compose? Isn't what you write a re…

Started by roger stancill

756 May 24, 2019
Reply by michael diemer

WAGNER'S RING (a political/philosophical question for all of us)

I just came across this. It is an article, imo, about the future of all live art music and about the future of all of us either as performe…

Started by Socrates Arvanitakis

38 Oct 16, 2018
Reply by Saul Dzorelashvili

Socrates, I'm up for some good-natured debate.

I am fascinated by your absolute rejection of "atonal". I agree that it is kind of a "catch-all" term. Yet so is "classical", for that matt…

Started by Bob Porter

25 Sep 12, 2018
Reply by H. S. Teoh

Is it harder to write fast music, or slow music?

Gav brought this up in his ballad thread. I'd like to hear everyone's thoughts on this, and expand it beyond his piece. A few ground rules.…

Started by Bob Porter

47 Jun 19, 2018
Reply by Lawrence Aurich


This thread's theme may be related to questions arising from Ray's recent threads on musical intentions/resulting performances and main req…

Started by Socrates Arvanitakis

4 Jul 31, 2017
Reply by H. S. Teoh

Beginner to intermediate composers

I don't know if anyone cares. But it has been awhile since I posted last on these forums. I have composed a lot since then. I have in all…

Started by andrew thornton

2 Jul 6, 2017
Reply by Socrates Arvanitakis

Music Dissection forum has been renamed

Hello everyone, the forum is now "Music Analysis and Critique"

Started by Gav Brown

1 Jun 10, 2017
Reply by George Abbott

Musical development: album or competition?

A few months ago I composed about 15 minutes of electronic music of various instruments/synthesizers using FL Studio. I had a theme that c…

Started by andrew thornton

2 May 14, 2017
Reply by Steve Chandler


Sign up info

Read before you sign up to find out what the requirements are!


© 2021   Created by Gav Brown.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service